Eagle Lake, FL Homes for Sale
Eagle Lake is a small lakeside city on US-17 between Winter Haven and Bartow, in central Polk County. It has more than doubled in size in recent years, from 3,008 residents in 2020 to an estimated 6,415 in 2025, according to the U.S. Census Bureau. Buyers come for a quieter setting, some homes on larger lots and quick access to Winter Haven.
About Eagle Lake
The city was settled around 1880, incorporated in 1921 and named for the lake at its center. Its median owner-occupied home value was $256,300 for 2020–2024, below the Polk County median. Homes range from older properties near the lakes to newer subdivisions.
What to check when buying here
- Well and septic: some homes outside city service areas use a private well or septic system. We recommend testing the water and inspecting the septic system.
- Lots and outbuildings: on larger lots, confirm property lines, permits for sheds or workshops and any easements.
- Flood zone: homes near the lakes may need flood insurance; we check before your inspection period ends.
Thinking of selling?
We'll show you what similar homes in Eagle Lake and nearby Winter Haven have sold for and build a marketing plan for your home.
Frequently asked questions
How far is Eagle Lake from Winter Haven? It borders Winter Haven to the south, a short drive up US-17.
Are there new homes in Eagle Lake? Yes, along with older resale homes. We can show you both.
Do you help in Spanish? Yes. Jamie and the team work in English and Spanish.
More: Winter Haven · Polk County · Living in Polk County